Vox Populi Issue 251

                                                            VOX POPULI

                                                                        by

                                                                  S Kamat 

                                                                        as

                                                                Aam Admi

                                           Issue: 251                        Date: 01.10.2018

                    Visit: skamat.blogspot.com or aamadmivoices.blogspot.com

 

Contents:         

1. Supreme Court Sabarimalai Temple Judgment Is Patently Wrong and 

    Erroneous

2. Tanushree Dutta's Allegations & The #meToo Movement

3. The Rupee Yo-Yo-ing On A Devaluation Roller Coaster

 Supreme Court Sabarimalai Temple Judgment Is Patently Wrong and Erroneous

The Supreme Court judgment in the Sabarimalai Temple case allowing the entry of women of all ages is patently wrong and erroneous. The woman Judge Indu Malhotra in her dissenting judgment in the case has succinctly said that in matters of religion and faith the courts have no right to interfere and should leave the matters to the religious leaders and elders in society. This coming from a woman in a case affecting women and which is likely to have ramifications across India in other temples is eminent wisdom. The aspect that even before the Constitution was framed these practices were in force establishes a precedent of sorts that the courts should not interfere in such matters. Looking at the matter just as ensuringz a right of access for women is very superficial and limited since these practices enjoin a tradition that has been going on through the ages. It is understood that there are moves by the Travancore Devaswom Board, the temple authorities and others who are not comfortable with the judgment to file a review petition in the Supreme Court which needs to be supported so that court interference in matters of religion is not accepted. 

                Tanushree Dutta's Allegations & The #meToo Movement

Tanushree Dutta allegations on the sexual harassment charge against Nana Patekar is in bad taste and also out of place. Sitting in the US and seeing the support for the #meToo movement, Tanushree Dutta seems to have had ideas to resurrect it in India. So a homecoming with a #meToo Bollywood version seemed a good idea and she launched into it without mulling on the implications. Again for a balanced person any incident more than a decade old is water that has flowed under the bridge and long gone. It is over. People have moved on. There is no point digging out old hurts because the person whom you will hurt the most is yourself. Another aspect of the #meToo movement even in the US is that people are getting tired of it but for the Weinstein saga. You did something either on the spur of the moment or for your career  or for love knowing full well the implications and then one fine day you wake up and start playing the victim. This is not acceptable behaviour among rational and sensible adults. The people on whom you cast aspersions are shocked and have to dig deeper into old wounds, maybe long forgotten. There is a broader sociological aspect about the #meToo movement and that is what women think about themselves and their position in society today. Until the 1960's and thereafter in the days of Women's Lib of Gloria Steinem and others, with women burning bras in public, it was thought that the woman is now liberated from the masculine shackles in which they were supposedly chained till then. The liberated independent woman with a mind of her own was welcomed mostly in western societies and other parts of the world to the extent that their societies would allow it. But one thinks that the #meToo movement is setting back the clock to the pre-Women's Lib days and wanting to portray the woman as a prey, vulnerable and in need of protection both physical as well as institutional like through the judiciary or whatever. Is this not retrograde thinking for the women, propagated by the women themselves?

                   The Rupee Yo-Yo-ing On A Devaluation Roller Coaster

There have been 3 unusual cycles of changes that we have been seeing lately when it comes to the Indian economy. Not in any particular order these are the value of the Rupee, the stock markets and fuel prices. While the Rupee has been yo-yoing about with the trend lines upwards in the last few weeks, the Sensex has been giving stock market investors a roller coaster of a ride in the last couple of months while fuel prices are on a unidirectional binge - higher, higher and still higher, again in the last few weeks. Such changes as we have been seeing recently in these three items are dramatic and have many ramifications on the lives of common people of this country.

The Rupee on a downward spiral against the US Dollar should have been contained by more energetic intervention by RBI. With the Rupee losing value leads to the rise in prices of almost every single item that is in the basket of daily necessities of the common man. The reason for this is not hard to find since we are dependent on imported oil and with landed prices of oil going up everything becomes costly because cost of transportation goes up. We have seen the Rupee depreciating in the past but it always had been effectively contained by RBI's intervention. This was at a time when our foreign exchange reserves were much lower than now where we are holding reserves in excess of US$ 300 Billion. With such reserves there should have been more comfort to try and hold the Rupee to reasonable levels. To explain the inaction we are being given many reasons like - Let the Rupee find its own level. It is also being said that any strong intervention will lead to sending wrong messages to the international community about India's sustained effort to pursue economic reforms. These arguments do not factor in the impact of the sliding Rupee on the common man's budget. And mind you this is happening when the Rupee is not fully convertible. You can therefore imagine what will happen when the Rupee becomes fully convertible which has to happen sooner or later if we are to join the comity of nations as a full-fledged economic player both in trade and services. India cannot participate on the world financial scene as a reluctant or unwilling donkey being pulled along by the dhobi or laundryman but become a pro-active and energetic player and show its competence in handling financial matters effectively and efficiently. Time for our present government to wake up and bite the bullet. 

                                                  ***********************

Vox Populi Issue 250

VOX POPULI                                                    by                                               S Kamat                                                      as                                               Aam Admi                          Issue: 250                  Date: 24.09.2018                     Visit: skamat.blogspot.com or aamadmivoices.blogspot.com Contents:          1. BJP's Many Psychoses Will Cost Them Heavily In The Upcoming Lok Sabha Elections 2. Modi's Corruption Robes Are Dappled In Black Akin A Dalmatian  3. Gen. Rawat Should Act More, Talk Less

  BJP's Many Psychoses Will Cost Them Heavily In The Upcoming Lok Sabha Elections

                               

         

The BJP is suffering from many psychoses. This includes the 'motor mouth' syndrome which we saw at its peak in the first half of this Modi government incumbency and which continues even now with random outbursts. The more recent is the 'spoilt brat syndrome'. In this as we have seen, the BJP leaders are free to call other people on the political scene all kinds of names and make all sorts of comments about them which in civilised society will not be considered acceptable behaviour. This includes Narendra Modi who descends to the depths of intemperance when it comes to a known Opposition party. But when it comes to taking back what they are dishing out to others the BJP leaders will yell foul and claim that the comments have crossed the borders of decorum. This particular comment is being made in the context of Nirmala Sitharaman saying that even when the Goa Chief Minister Manohar Parrikar is sick the Congress party is trying to de-stabilise the State government without any compunctions of sympathy. Being a relatively new politician she probably does not know that alls fair in love, war and also politics. This is precisely the  'spoilt brat syndrome' which is when you create nuisance for others you convince yourself and others that you are in the right but the moment the opponents respond in kind, you are not able to take it and cry out in protest. The BJP leaders need to grow up and show more maturity by being able to take as much as they can give. The other thing is, like we have seen the BJP leaders have ever since the win in the Lok Sabha elections in 2014 come across as too full of their own importance. In this ego trip we have seen them say outrageous things and act with ridiculous abandon. The latest being just last week in 2 incidents. The first when a Jharkhand BJP MP's feet were washed and the water was drunk by a party worker and the second when a MLA in U.P.  forcing the railway attendant to open a level crossing and then parking his car across the tracks thus blocking train services for a few hours. Most of the BJP leaders including ministers in the Central government are incompetent or have reached their level of incompetence. All these tendencies arise out of the BJP being new to government. Thus they either have this habit of lecturing the nation believing that all people are the kind who will swallow all that they say or throw their weight around aggressively in trying to suppress contra-opinions. In other context where the BJP have in the past been accusing previous governments of paralysis in governance and decision making, we have them doing the same thing in Goa where with Manohar Parrikar, the Chief Minister being in and out of hospitals since February 2018 with a serious ailment along with at least 3 ministers of his Cabinet being similarly incapacitated, the Goa government is in a 'coma' or suspended animation with nothing moving. The fact of trying to cling to power without delivering in governance and being irresponsive to common man needs is going to cost the BJP heavily in the upcoming Lok Sabha elections scheduled in 2019. 

             Modi's Corruption Robes Are Dappled In Black Akin A Dalmatian 

Just like a skein of wool the Rafale deal is coming unravelled, one thread at a time. The latest is the French ex- President, Hollande's statement that the name of the Anil Ambani led Reliance Aerospace as offset partner for the deal came from India. Diplomatic nicety stops him from disclosing the name of the person from the Indian side who suggested the name of Reliance. With this the scams in this Modi government are bigger than in the UPA I & II. In the Rafale deal the pay-off is almost 10 times that of Bofors as far as scams in defence purchases are concerned. The Defence Minister wanting to collect brownie points had recently made a comment that the Modi government had eliminated agents from defence purchases but she did not say that the conduit is now through crony capitalists as the Rafale deal is showing up. Similarly the Nirav Modi/Choksi fraud is almost double that of the Mallya scam at Rs. 16,000 crore. Where the Modi government wanted to cloak itself in white robes of purity as far as corruption is concerned, it is now being seen that this position is coming unstuck and the pristine white is being dappled with black spots akin to a Dalmatian. The analogy is being used to suit Modi's sartorial style since even clothed in corruption, one is sure that he would like to see himself look good.

                                 Gen. Rawat Should Act More, Talk Less

For a professional soldier Gen. Rawat, our Chief Of Army Staff tends to align himself  and play to the political overtones of military action. Like recently after the mutilation of the Indian jawan at the hands of the Pakistani state and non-state actors, he is getting into the act by saying that we should retaliate and give the Pakistanis a bloody nose, not in as many words though. He should have done what he proposed and then came and told us the results of his action. One would expect thus that he should go about his job of defending our borders quietly and looking after his soldiers with dedication, he more often than not shoots off his mouth. Even during the episode of the surgical strike he had the tendency to wade into the details of it, feeding fire to the subsequent controversy while a professional soldier would have stood quietly on the sidelines and watched the fun and games that his political masters play. In fact when Prakash Javdekar, our Human Resources Minister asked the UGC to send out an instruction to educational institutions around the country to celebrate Surgical Strike Day, Gen. Rawat should have told him that undercover operations be best kept under wraps. That is the way you ensure that they remain effective. When our political leaders are blasé about certain matters it is the duty of the professionals, in this case Gen. Rawat to correct them. That is what we would expect from the boss of the Indian Army. 

                                                       ************************

Vox Populi Issue 249

                                  VOX POPULI

                                           by

                                      S Kamat 

                                            as

                                     Aam Admi                               
             Issue: 249                 Date: 17.09.2018

      Visit: skamat.blogspot.com or aamadmivoices.blogspot.com

Contents:         

1. Tall Claims & A 56" Chest

2. Common Logic About The Economy Turned On Its Head

3. Nirmala Sitharaman Needs To Tone Up On The Rafale Deal & Pursue Democratic   

     Principles

4. Modi's Gujarat Model At Work

                                           Tall Claims & A 56" Chest

Narendra Modi and his government has been consistently losing credibility from the time they took office in 2014. Maybe that is the reason for some of his bombastic statements that are being made from time to time and which are increasing on the magnitude of the claim from one to the other. Like the latest one that India has become cleaner in the last 4 years than in the previous 65 years. If you look around you, you know that this is not true since you still find garbage strewn on the roads, animal poop dot our roads and open spaces, there is litter all around along with construction material. People still go out with their lotas or in the new avatar, plastic bottles in the morning to do their ablutions though it is claimed that the country is moving towards OD - Outdoor Defecation free status. These claims are in the nature of good sloganeering but bad in fact. 

Similarly some time back it was claimed that all villages in India or some 90% of them have been provided with electricity. Very soon after that newspapers carried news of large swathes of the country mostly in the rural areas not having  been provided connections for electricity. 

The major credibility issue of Modi and his government is about economic indices and to show among them in an almost obsessive way that the GDP growth is close to 8%. For this since 2014 this BJP government changed the base years so that the GDP figures are given a more rosy hue. But unfortunately in the manner of a stalled engine for no apparent reason the GDP recently has not been able to go just a tad beyond 7%. It has also been lately put out in the public domain that the growth in both UPA 1 & 2 had been better than that of the BJP since 2014. This has brought about the need to be more raucous about any GDP growth that just crossed 7% like in the April-June 2018 quarter. This   celebration was somewhat neutralised by proving that the previous year same quarter the figures were not so good for comparison and hence the present year's quarter tipping the 7% mark. It is not just the GDP figures but also the CPI, WPI, the IIP and every conceivable economic indice this government has fiddled with. The resultant effect is that no one believes the figures on the India economy that the government puts out. This has made any growth suspect like the IIP indicated a spurt in industrial production from a consistent straight fall in the last 5 quarters but it took a while for the country to digest it. The reaction was to wait and see another month to confirm the reality of this growth. 

Even on jobs data, it is the same situation where 1 crore jobs were promised but lately when the issue came up that though this government has been talking about growth and even if it has been there it has not resulted in increase in jobs. The charge has been that it is jobless growth. To counter this charge the government came up with figures saying it has created lakhs of jobs mainly in government. While this data is again doubtful the government in its anxiety to prove its point has failed to realise that between a lakh and a crore there is a factor of 100. In fact that reflects the margin of claims versus achievement of this Modi government. Talk big, talk tall but comparable factual performance is minuscule and sometimes you need a magnifying glass to verify the  government's claims.

There was also talk of a 56" chest a couple of years back, oft repeated since then, which also needs to be verified. It may not be true since rarely does rhyming reflect the fact of actual physical attributes. There has been also some time that has passed since the first claim which may have changed the 56" for better or for worse. Give or take a few inches. That's life, Mr Modi!

                         Common Logic About The Economy Turned On Its Head

Price indices for the common man used to be the market price of onions, potatoes and petrol/diesel. For the little educated, a booming stock market  and a relatively strong Rupee meant 'all is well' with the economy. Now all this common wisdom has been turned on its head by the present BJP government. Prices for petrol/diesel are running amok. Not even when a few ears ago international prices of oil were US$ 100 a barrel, did the domestic prices of petrol touch Rs. 90 per litre as they are doing now in Mumbai, when International prices of oil are hovering between US$ 70-75 a barrel. The government is doing nothing about it but asking us to hold our breath and wait for the prices to fall. The same with the Rupee where we are told that the 'Rupee must find its true level'. In the meanwhile imports are becoming costlier creating an inflationary situation in the economy. This trend is being compounded with the rising fuel prices leading to a cost push for transportation which is already seeing a rise in prices of vegetables and other essential commodities. While all this is happening, as said earlier, the government is doing nothing but watching the fun as it were from the sidelines. In both cases that of fuel prices and the Rupee rate there was a need for intervention by using our reserves of foreign exchange which this government has refused to do or has not fathomed the need to do because of being inept or because of the Finance Minister being away or to put it simply - sheer cussedness. Prices a short while ago for oil were hovering at US$ 50 a barrel at which time we could have built a buffer stock with the foreign exchange reserves that we had. This would have held us in good stead at this time with the government at least able to think on the option at an attempt to control fuel prices. Without that the common man is being exposed to the double whammy of rising fuel prices and a weakening Rupee. And a minister in the Rajasthan cabinet tells # that we need to curb expenses so that we can pay for the rising fuel prices. The same thing with the Rupee where the RBI should have intervened effectively to hold the value and has been done in the past. It’s nothing new for the RBI but it looks like a game of attrition is being played out as to who would blink first between them and the government. These are the mind games being played between institutions like the RBI and the government and the economy is being allowed to drift aimlessly. It s time that Modi and his team screw their heads properly on their necks and looked at the betterment of the common man and the economy. 

                       Nirmala Sitharaman Needs To Tone Up On The Rafale Deal 

                                              & Pursue Democratic Principles

Nirmala Sitharaman, Defence Minister is acting with rank stupidity in trying to defend the procurement of the Rafale fighters from France. In her various statements lately she is tying herself in knots trying to defend the indefensible. She is probably out of her depth when she says that in the deal negotiated by the previous UPA government, the whole thing fell through since HAL refused to guarantee the aircraft that they were supposed to produce under a joint program with Dassault Aviation. Firstly, we need to recognise that this is not the first time that HAL are going into a joint program for manufacture of aircraft with a foreign Co. All the aircraft that the IAF uses have been produced by HAL. So one would have to believe that HAL knows what they are talking about when it comes to the guarantee. This BJP government seems to think that on any matter because it is new to them, it is also new to the country. That is not the fact. In contrast the Defence Minister is for the first time into her job and she has to learn a lot still. As for the guarantee in a joint program of manufacture involving localisation of high technology products like aircraft, it is normally a joint guarantee given by the local manufacturer and the foreign collaborator. Only when full localisation is achieved then only can a Co. like HAL give a guarantee for the aircraft that too with a back-to-back guarantee on the sub-systems that they will get from the foreign Co.

In another statement, Nirmala Sitharaman has said that she finds it not necessary to engage with the Opposition on the Rafale deal since they only tend to misconstrue the issue. This is highly irresponsible to first make a mess of a 'done' deal then when the Opposition raises issues to call them trouble-makers. The simple thing is that if there is nothing wrong with the deal then put out a White Paper on it. That will close the matter. In a democracy if you refuse to engage with stakeholders and clarify a matter that has come into the public domain, then it smacks of unilateralism. To also say that the people of India have no issue on the matter is trying to steamroll public opinion. You do not tell the people the prices at which the Rafale fighters are being bought and other details about the contract but claim that it is acceptable to them!

The Reliance deal for local offsets that can run up to 30% of the contract value, is being claimed by the Defence Minister that technically she is not aware of. According to her the foreign Co. is not contractually bound to tell the government with whom they will implement the offset arrangement. This is again something that just does not sound right. The government needs to know the credentials of the offset manufacturer since then they are reassured that the contract will be performed satisfactorily. Otherwise we will have what has happened now where the Anil Ambani Co. with no background and experience in aerospace gets the offset contract for the Rafale deal. As far as Nirmala Sitharaman's comment about ignorance of the offset manufacturer, all she had to do was pick up the phone and talk to Narendra Modi who surely knew all along about the identity of the offset manufacturer.    

                                         Modi's Gujarat Model At Work

We are seeing yet again the Gujarat model at work being put through by our Prime Minister Narendra Modi in the context of rising fuel prices. Just like in the 2002 Gujarat communal riots Modi did nothing in the first couple of days allowing the rioters to literally run riot across Gujarat, so also now fuel prices are being allowed to spiral beyond control with Modi not even lifting his little finger to allow some relief to the common man. We have seen this prevarication and indecision till almost the point of no return since 2014 many times starting with the intolerance Issue, then it was the polarisation of university students at JNU and Osmania University with the dubious intent of controlling the student's unions and thus the student voice, then it was the lynching of mostly Muslims & Dalits on various cow charges, then on the rape of the girl child and women across the country which in brutality in some cases was in excess of the Nirbhaya incident in 2012 at Delhi. On crimes against women the nation wondered that Modi who has at most times a voice preferred to remain mute except to make a lame statement late in the day that we need to respect women in our society though one must grant his government for having passed a stringent law against rapists that goes up to capital punishment for raping minors. Where in matters related to the common man and relief and sympathy to him Modi and his government have been remiss, they have with great alacrity and a sense of purpose put through measures like Demonetisation and GST which have loaded misery on the common man for no great economic gains or for showing this government's administrative ability to put through major reforms. In most matters related to the nation there is a tendency to blame the previous UPA regimes or the Congress party to a point where one needs to ask that after being almost 5 years in power what has the Modi government done? Have they achieved anything? Nothing tangible has been achieved except for shows of bluff and bluster.  

                                            **********************************

Vox Populi Issue 248

                                     VOX POPULI

                                                 by

                                            S Kamat 

                                                  as

                                            Aam Admi
                   Issue: 248             Date: 10.09.2018

              Visit: skamat.blogspot.com or aamadmivoices.blogspot.com

Contents:                

1. BJP Leaders Should Show More Maturity

2. No Action To Control Domestic Fuel Prices

3. Rape Is A Disease In Our Society And A Cure Is Required On A War Footing

WISHING YOU ALL A HAPPY GANESH CHATURTHI. MAY LORD GANESHA FILL YOUR LIFE WITH HIS BOUNTIFUL BLESSINGS.

                                       BJP Leaders Should Show More Maturity

BJP leaders are filled up with their own importance and care little about the people. An  incident in the last week in Tamil Nadu highlight these tendencies. A young girl student raised slogans about the BJP being a 'fascist regime' and denigrating it on board a flight from Chennai to Tuticorin and also upon landing at Tuticorin airport with the trigger being possibly that the student had spotted the BJP-in-charge lady for Tamil Nadu on the flight. The BJP leader as understood by the reports in the media went hammer and tongs at the young student to the extent of getting her arrested on the charge for inciting public unrest. This while the police, airport authorities and even bystanders requesting the BJP leader to let the matter pass since the student may not even know what she is saying. But the lady politician did not relent leaving the police no option but to arrest the student. This satisfied the ego of the BJP leader who if she had good humouredly gone and asked the student the meaning of fascism and why she was behaving in this manner could possibly have defused the situation. Like they say when there is an age difference between the interactors in any situation, a little humour can go a long way. But then among the ranks of the BJP in Tamil Nadu humour may be in short supply. Not only that for this lady it was a question of losing face since she would have attracted derision for not putting down dissent and acting with authority in the matter. In this issue, there is the amusing sideline as to why the BJP leader was not arrested by the TN police for causing public unrest because she was making much more noise than the student? Maybe the TN police may like to explain. 

Continuing on the theme that BJP leaders should show more maturity. At a 'dahi handi' event in his constituency in Ghatkopar West last week the BJP MLA Kadam announced in public that the boys can point out any girl that they have a fancy for and he would have the girl kidnapped provided the boy agrees that he would marry the girl. In this we are back into the caveman age where you could carry away any woman to your liking and have the leader legitimise the abduction upon a show of strength with any other contender for the woman's hand. 

                             No Action To Control Domestic Fuel Prices

This BJP government is utterly insensitive to citizen's problems, their interest and well-being. This is being said in the context of the comments made recently by the BJP spokesperson, Nalin Kohli on the spiralling rise in prices of petrol and diesel that we have been seeing the last few days. The hike could be because of international oil prices and the deprecating Rupee, but to say that the hikes are in the interest of the economy and is beneficial to the Centre and the States since their revenues increase it is forgotten that oil is a commodity of daily necessity for the common man and it is his purchase that gets the government its revenue. With rising prices all around him starting with food, basic necessities in which petrol figures, his back is getting broken time and again with almost the daily increases of fuel prices. Where the government should have been sensitive to the plight of the common man and looked at methods of reducing his burden, there seems to be a certain amount of glee in claiming that the government stands to gain from the rising prices. Sometime back there was talk that the Centre would reduce the Excise Duty on petroleum products and maybe even Customs duty and in turn persuade the States to reduce their Sales Tax, since petrol and diesel happen to be the highest taxed items. This would have reduced the price then by about Rs. 5 per litre which today maybe would be Rs. 7. However from Nalin Kohli's statement one would believe that forget any reduction in taxes and duties, this government seems to be cheering the increase in fuel prices and waving it along higher and higher. The problem is that BJP functionaries and spokespersons rarely apply their mind in any great detail to any issue. Their tendency is to look for the sound byte and come up with off-the-cuff responses which takes the easiest position to justify the event or action on hand. This is surely irresponsible and callous on the part of this government which has forgotten or plainly put does not see the point that governments need also to be benevolent. 

      Rape Is A Disease In Our Society And A Cure Is Required On A War Footing

The issue of rape of women in our society is not being tackled properly. The problem is deep rooted in the psyches of our men and needs to be taken more seriously than what is being done today where it is equated to a crime like petty theft or burglary believing that making a law will deter those that commit rape. Even the PM the other day made a statement that rapes will not be tolerated and that his government has made a more stringent law to deal with rapes of particularly minors which involves among other stringent punishments for rapists, the death sentence to those who rape minor girls below 12 years. This was very much required. We need to fast track all rape cases and if within a span of 3 months from the occurrence of the rape the attacker is hanged, it will send a message out to likely rapists that the government means business and they better be wary and desist from their heinous plans. However, this law will serve in a limited way since the offenders are rarely thinking of the consequence of their actions while performing the offence and even beyond that as we all know our justice system is slow to act and our police who are expected to investigate and bring the cases to court are easily influenced if not purchasable. 

Rape in Indian society has been a continuing phenomenon but it raised national remorse after the Nirbhaya case in 2012 where the sheer bestiality of the incident left the nation horrified. But nothing happened after that to limit the rape incidents with cases dotting across the length and breadth of the nation to this day. The Unnao, Kathua and Surat rape cases with their callousness and brutality show that after the Nirbhaya incident nothing really has changed in the way that women particularly children and even infants are seen by men not as human beings but as objects to satisfy their lust and sexual aberrations. Neither was justice delivered to rapists quickly since then, with even the culprits of the Nirbhaya case only now after close to 6 years finally being sent to the gallows. The main instigator of the Nirbhaya incident on the basis of being a minor was let off by the juvenile court with a limited sentence in a remand home. Not only that case but for the numerous incidents of rape since then, our police and justice system lumber on to serve punishment to the rapists. Attached is a listing of attack and rape cases on women since 29th June 2018 which do not include crimes of passion and/or romance or those where a certain amount of prior knowledge between the rapist and the victim is indicated or related to assumed connivance by the victim. This information is culled from 8 mainline national newspapers and highlights the lack of safety of women in India as women and girl children go about their normal daily lives. The sheer randomness indicated by these 64 cases over 73 days, making it in an average of almost one incident per day, preclude women from anticipating such attacks and seeking protection and highlight the predatory approach of the men involved. The actual number of incidents could be higher since many cases go unreported due to either the police unwillingness to register a case or perceived social stigma from the victim or her family. If one scans these 64 cases you will find that the problem of rape is deep rooted in the minds of the Indian male. There is a need of a detailed study done on this by a panel of psychiatrists who need to come out quickly with a set of concrete measures to change this mind-set. In addition a sustained multimedia advertising campaign needs to be launched on the need to respect the female sex of all ages and not necessarily from the immediate family but women and girl  children at large. The intensity of the campaign should be equivalent to the earlier ones that we had som3 years ago to limit the size of the family - Ek Ya Do Bas. Chota Parivar Sukhi Parivar. Or the birth control campaign featuring the use of Nirodh. The present campaign on the girl child - Beti Bachao, Beti Padhao - needs to be expanded to cover all women as well as to bring in the aspect of rape. Otherwise what is happening now is that  - Beti Bachao, Beti Padhao Aur Uske Baad Rape Karo. A disconcerting thing about this matter is that the focus of our government is somewhat cursory and lopsided. We have a woman Maneka Gandhi as Woman & Child Welfare Minister who has not raised her voice on rape except in the last few days when rapes were found to be happening in shelter homes. However she writes on Animal Welfare almost every weekend in major newspapers of the country and is known to be an animal lover. This shows how much she is doing in her ministry and for the female sex. 

Rape is being treated as an event and instead of prevention the government is concentrating on the rehabilitation of the victims. Though this is important the emphasis should have been on stopping rape cases that happen publicly. We need to understand that if we reduce the incidence of rape then we save the victim from the pain, suffering and trauma and less will be the need for rehabilitation funds. Lately in France the lady Minister in charge of women affairs has launched a program by which men who are involved in eve teasing on the streets are intercepted within minutes by the police who are entrusted with this ask and enjoined to take crimes against women on priority. Though granted we have more people on our streets which may make it difficult to intercept miscreants but the issue is the police attitude we have here which does not even register rape cases and sometimes discourages rape complaints. And also we have a woman Minister for women and child affairs who is least bothered about rape. Coming back to the rehabilitation issue after the Nirbhaya case a Rs. 1 crore fund was set up in 2013. Even after 2 years in 2015 it was found that hardly a couple of Lakhs was disbursed from the fund though rapes continued unabated which means our bureaucracy continues in its stodgy insistence on government procedures. Rape is a disease in our society and therefore we need to tackle it on a war footing. 

Crimes Against Women Mostly Rapes Since 29.6.2018:
__________________________________________________________

67. A 28 year old woman, an anganwadi worker, while returning home with her brother on a bike were intercepted by 3 men and after assaulting the brother took away the woman to a nearby farmhouse and raped her by turns and abandoned her there. The incident took place on 10.9.2018 evening at Kukudajhar village under Sadar police station of Dhenkanal district. The woman was rescued by her brother and the police from the farmhouse after she gave a call to her brother and a case was registered after which the 3 men were arrested and the car used in the kidnap was also seized. Date: 12.9.2018. Source: National newspapers.

66. A 14 year old girl was beaten up in public by villagers upon the orders of a khap panchayat for daring to file an FIR after she was raped by a 65 year old man of the her village. The incident happened in the village Bishnupur in Chattisgarh's north Bastar village of Kanker and the police case was filed in Bande police station. Date: 12.9.2018. Source: National newspapers.

65. A 27 year old man has been arrested for touching inappropriately and molesting a 26 year old woman in Bandra West, Mumbai on Sept 6 & 7 while she was walking with her mother to go to church on Mount Mary Road. Date: 10.9.2018. Source: National newspapers.

64. A 42 year old priest of the Khola Mandir in South Delhi has been arrested for molesting a 15 year old girl when she had gone with her woman relative to the temple. The priest has been arrested on Sept 2. Date: 4.9.2018. Source: National newspapers.

63. A 27 year old engineer woman was held captive and raped regularly and head tonsured after she met a man in his Andheri West, Mumbai flat in mid-June 2018 and was offered some sweet laced with a sedative. The woman finally escaped on Aug 25 and fled to Pune to her relative when a FIR was lodged and the rapist arrested. Date: 4.9.2018. Source: National newspapers.

62. A 14 year old girl from the near extinct Sabar tribe was raped in Ghurabandha village near Jamshedpur in Jharkhand, then strung up on a tree to simulate suicide and then buried by her friend's father. He was assisted in hiding this crime by other members of his tribe who have all - 7 - been detained. The incident happened on Aug 28 when the 2 girls were found missing but the victim returned same evening while her friend went away with her boyfriend. The father of the missing girl then suspecting the victim about his missing daughter took her into the forest and on the pretext of questioning her, raped and killed her. He then strung her up on a tree and later buried her with the help of other members of the tribe. In the meanwhile his daughter came back n her own on Aug 30. The case came to light when a local TV channel reported the case of a girl committing suicide after hanging from a tree. This prompted the police to investigate. Date: 1.9.2018. Source: National newspapers.

61. A 12 year old girl claimed to have been touched inappropriately in the school canteen at Kandivali during recess in the crowd at the food counter when she was in front of a bunch of male students. The student who committed the act is yet to be identified. The incident happened on 30th Aug 2018. A police case has been filed. Date: 1.9.2018. Source: National newspapers.

60. An Australian woman in her mid-20's who had come t attend her friend's wedding in Khar was abused and molested on 29th Aug 2018 on Hill Road, Bandra West in Mumbai in the afternoon on the street by a 30 year old man who has since been arrested after being identified through CCTV footage. Date: 1.9.2018. Source: National newspapers.

59. A 28 year old woman immolated herself in Shahjahanpur, U.P. with police refusing to register a rape case on her by her neighbour on Aug 18, 2018. Her husband said she was mentally very upset with the incident and the police not willing to pursue the case. Date: 31.8.2018. Source: National newspapers.

58. A 15 year old girl raped by her neighbour in April 2018 and who has become pregnant has been threatened along with her father in village Laksar, near Roorkee in Uttarakhand by the people of the village and the panchayat to terminate the pregnancy and not report the case to the police. However, with a police complaint being filed some 20 villagers have been arrested and strictures issued on the panchayat not to issue such fatwas. Date: 31.8.2018. Source: National newspapers.

57. A  Class XI girl was dragged into the cane fields in Ghaziabad and raped by 2 men with another keeping watch while she was returning from an adjoining village where she had gone on her bicycle to photocopy some notes. The police are investigating the suspects named by the girl and her father. Date: 31.8.2018. Source: National newspapers.

56. A 11 year old girl was raped in the basement of a Gurgaon multi-storey residential society by a 22 year old student living in the same complex. Date: 31.8.2018. Source: National newspapers.

55. Man gropes 25 year old woman at Dadar station, whips out knife. Caught by RPF before he could hurt anyone. Date: 30.8.2018. Source: National newspapers.

54. A 30 year old woman security guard was molested by an inebriated man at a mall  on Sohna Road on 26 Aug 2018 when she was going to the toilet at about 10.45pm. Upon the woman raising an alarm some late movie goers at the multiplex inside the mall caught the man and handed him over to the police. Date: 28.8.2018. Source: National newspapers.

53. A 16 year old girl was confined to a room by a private security guard in Gurgaon's Chauma village and regularly raped over that period was freed and found to be 2 months pregnant. The incident was reported to the local Child Welfare Committee (CWC) by the victim and arrangements are being made to help abort the foetus to help the girl forget about her travails during the 3 month period. Date: 28.8.2018. Source: National newspapers.

52. A 19 year old woman while going into the fields of Kotla village in Medway of Nuh district was abVducted by 4 men of the village and raped multiple times. The rapists also took videos of the action and uploaded it onto social media on Saturday when the crime was reported to the police. The attackers are still absconding. This was reported from out of Gurgaon by TOI. Date: 28.8.2018. Source: National newspapers.

51. A 58 year old woman was thrown onto the tracks hurting herself seriously by a person trying to snatch her handbag which she refused to let go in Mumbai between Masjid and Sandhurst stations at 8am. The elderly lady was travelling by the Udayan Express to Bengaluru on Aug 22, 2018. The attacker has been arrested on Sunday, 26th Aug 2018 while the woman with a broken hip, fractures on her right arm and a cut palm is recovering in hospital. Date: 28.8.2018. Source: National newspapers.

50. A 20 year old man was arrested in Barhariya of Siwan district, Bihar for raping and killing a 4 year old girl after luring her from a wedding feast on 25th Aug 2018. Date: 27.8.2018. Source: National newspapers.

49. A 22 year old woman was shot dead in an incident while her phone was being snatched by a masked man in Katihar when she was returning with her lady friend after buying rakhi on 25th Aug 2018. Date: 27.8.2018. Source: National newspapers.

48. An 18 year old girl was assaulted in a Mumbai local train and thrown off the moving train at Mumbra station @ 9 am in the morning while resisting the snatching of her hi-end mobile phone. Based on the CCTV recordings the attacker a Mumbra resident was arrested. Date 26.8.2018. Source: National newspapers.

47. A 21 year old physically challenged girl was raped and then stripped and left in a paddy field by 2 youths in Kasba town of Bihar's Purnea district on 23rd Aug 2018. 

Date: 25.8.2018. Source: National newspapers.

46. A 16 year old girl employed in the kitchen of an old age home atChiluatal in Gorakhpur district, U.P. and staying on the premises was raped over a period of 10 days by the old age home manager who has since been arrested. Date 25.8.2018. Source: National newspapers.

45. A 13 year old girl was raped and killed by her 24 year old neighbour in Bhiwandi near Mumbai on 23 rd Aug 2018 evening. The man has since been arrested. Date 25.8.2018. Source: National newspapers.

44. A 11 year old girl was raped and then attempted to be strangled by a masked youth when she had gone to attend nature's call at 8.30pm on 22nd August 2018 at Rangpuri Pahad in South Delhi. The girl survived after she was left for dead in a nearby bit and was taken to AIIMS where she was operated upon. Based upon the girl's description a number of youth have been detained and questioned to establish the identity of the attacker. Date 24.8.2018. Source: National newspapers.

43.A. A 6 year old girl while returning from a flag hoisting ceremony on Aug 15 was abducted and raped by 2 persons in Sukhpura in Ballia district. One of the attackers has been arrested. Date 20.8.2018. Source: National newspapers.

43. In another case in Gadwar of the same Ballia district as above a minor girl was held captive and raped in a field by a fellow villager on 18 Aug. Date 20.8.2018. Source: National newspapers.

42. A. A 15 year old was lured by two sisters, her close friends, after drugging her and then taken to be raped by 2 male friends in Manikpur town of Korba district, Chhattisgarh. The sisters and their male friends have been arrested. Date 19.8.2018. Source: National newspapers.z

42. A teenage girl in Sardhana town of Meerut district was set on fire by a group of men by pouring kerosene on her for refusing to talk to them on the phone. They used to eve tease the girl while going to her coaching institute. The girl survived and is being treated for burns at the local hospital. Some of the men involved have been arrested. Date 19.8.2018. Source: National newspapers.

41. A 12 year old girl was raped and murdered in Uttarkashi by some construction labourers from outside the State. Some of the suspects have been taken into custody.

Date 19.8.2018. Source: National newspapers.

40. A 6 year old (variously reported as a 3 year old whose arm was also dismembered in the attack) was raped and murdered and then her body dumped among some bushes in a farm in a village in Raisen district of M.P. after she was lured with a sweet by someone known to the victim's family. The attacker has since been arrested. Date 17.8.2018. Source: National newspapers.

39. Police arrested a tuition teacher for sexually assaulting a 15 year old girl over 3 months in a northern suburb of Mumbai who was kept back on the pretext of an extra lecture after the other students had left. Date 16.8.2018. Source: National newspapers.

38. 7 inmates of a women short-stay shelter home in Haripur, Bihar run by a private NGO are suspected to have been molested and raped by the Vaishali district program manager who has been arrested along with others on charges of rape and abetment of rape. Date 15.8.2018. Source: National newspapers.

37. A 13 year old girl in Bahraich, U.P., studying in a residential school was raped while being taken home for a medical ailment. The youth who raped her has been arrested. Date 13.8.2018. Source: National newspapers.

36. A 12 year old girl was aped by three men when she had gone out in the night to relieve herself in Bagalkot, Karnataka. Date 12.8.2018. Source: National newspapers.

35. A Cl. 2 girl has been raped in a Delhi Govt. school by the electrician. The man has been arrested. Date 10.8.2018. Source: TV News.

34. A Juhu couple has been arrested for raping 2 minor girls hired as household help multiple times. The man for the act and the wife for helping the rapes to happen. The couple have since been arrested. Date 10.8.2018. Source: National newspapers.

33. A deaf-mute has been raped a number of times by the director of a shelter home in which she was housed in Bhopal. The case since expanded with 3 more inmates of the home accusing the owner of molestation, unnatural sex and rape. Date 10.8.2018. Source: National newspapers. & Date 13.8.2018. Source: TV News.

32. A 5 year old infant was raped and then strangled to death by a man who was later caught in Ghaziabad. Date 8.8.2018. Source: National newspapers.

31. In a similar incident to the Bihar shelter home rape case, 24 minor girls are suspected to  have been raped by different individuals in Deoria, U.P out of 42 girls in the NGO run shelter home with the remaining 18 reported missing. The girls would be sent out by the lady manager of the NGO as reported in cars arriving at the home in the afternoon and returning back late in the night crying. Date 6.8.2018. Source: National newspapers & TV news.

30. A woman in Mehsana town in Gujarat depressed after Lang a child recently after hiring an auto-rickshaw  was raped by the driver along with 3 others at different places. 

Date 6.8.2018. Source: National newspapers.

29. An eight month pregnant woman was raped by 4 men while her husband was locked up in their car at Turchi Phata in Tasgaon near Sangli town in Maharashtra over supposedly a business dispute. Date 3.8.2018. Source: National newspapers.

28. 17 year old girl raped in Bengaluru by mobile shop owner/cab driver by posing as a police officer to drive away the girl's male companion showing a fake gun and then forcing the girl into his cab and raping her near Chikkabommasandra, Yelahanka New Town. Date 28.7.2018. Source: National newspapers.

27. In a government shelter home 29 girls (revised since to 34 after medical examination was done on other inmates) have been found to be raped in Muzaffarpur district of Bihar. Arrests have been made of those that run the home. Suspicion of influential people in the area with close political connections to be involved in the rapes.

Date 24.7.2018. Source: National newspapers.

There has been another case of a 21 year old raped in another Bihar shelter home.
Date 27.7.2018. Source: National newspapers.

26. 4 women beaten up in Dawkimari village, Jalpaiguri district in Bengal on suspicion of being child lifters. 2 of them were disrobed. Date 24.7.2018. Source: National newspapers.

25. A 25 year old woman was beaten to death suspecting her to be a childlifter in Morwa region of Singrauli district, MP. Date 23.7.2018. Source: National newspapers.

24. A 16 year old girl from Puducherry was raped by 4 youth from adjacent Villupuram district where she had come visiting her grandmother. Date 23.7.2018. Source: National newspapers.

23. A Muslim man was lynched at Alwar, Rajasthan on suspicion of being involved in cow trafficking. Date 22.7.2018. Source: TV News & National newspapers.

22. A 22 year old woman was raped under sedation by some 40 men over a period of 4  days at a guest house in Morni, Panchkula District, Haryana where she was employed as a caretaker by one of the men involved. An SIT has been constituted to investigate the case and apprehend the culprits. Date 21.7.2018. Source: TV News & National newspapers.

21. A 19 year old girl from Nagaland was raped by 2 men in Kakrola area of Dwarka in Delhi. Date 21.7.2018. Source: National newspapers.

20. A 11 year old hearing-impaired girl was raped over months in the heart of Chennai by 17 men including the security guard of the building where the girl used to live. Date 17.7.2018. Source: TV News & National newspapers. 

19. A 6 year old girl was abducted in the heart of Delhi by a eunuch and raped on the night of 14th July 2018. Date 17.7.2018.Source: National newspapers.

18. A man was lynched in Handikhera village near Bidar, Karnataka by a mob on suspicions of being a child lifter. 3 other associates of the victim were severely beaten up. Date: 16.7.2018. Source: National newspapers.

17. A mentally unsound woman was raped in a NGO run short stay home SSH by the security guard in Bihar's Saran district resulting in the victim's pregnancy. The guard and the SSH manager has been held. Date: 15.7.2018. Source: National newspapers.

16. A 35 year old woman, a mother of 2 children, was gang raped by 5 men and then torched in the yagnashala of a temple in a village under Rajpura police station of UP's Sambhal district. Date: 15.7.2018. Source: National newspapers.

15. A  minor girl raped by BJP MLA Sengar in June 2017 at Makhi village of Unnao, UP. Then gangraped within another fortnight by a group of men. Father arrested on trumped up charges in April 2018 and dies thereafter of injuries allegedly inflicted by brother of above MLA. Girl threatens immolation in front of UP CM's residence. With this & public pressure case transferred to CBI now. Date: 12.7.2018. Source: National newspapers.

14. 16 year old girl immolates herself after gang rape in Baruipur, Bengal. Date 9.7.2018.Source: National newspapers.

13. Businessman in Gurugram rapes daughter's friend. Date 08.7.2018. Source: TV News.

12. 3 men molest a woman in Unnao, UP, while a 4th man films it & the video goes viral. Date 06.7.2018. Source: TV News.

11. 14 year old girl gang-raped in Sagar, MP. Date 5.7.2018.Source: IANS/Goa newspaper.

10. 19 year old girl raped by 4 men in a forest at Dewas, MP. Date 5.7.2018.Source: National newspapers.

9. 15 year old girl raped by 3 of her elder brother's friends with 2 of them being minors in the Bada Patthar area of Jabalpur. Date 4.7.2018.Source: National newspapers.

8. 3 year child raped in the Kanota area on the outskirts of Jaipur. Date 4.7.2018.Source: National newspapers.

7. Dalit Woman, Raped & Paraded Naked In UP - incident happened in Kurara village of Hamirpur District. Date 4.7.2018.Source: National newspapers.

6. In MP again at village Panna, a 4 year old girl was raped and the child was left for dead in a secluded spot. The rapist was caught and handed over to the police while the child is fighting for her life in hospital. Date 2/3.7.2018.Source: National newspapers & TV News.

5. In Dhule, Maharashtra 5 persons were lynched, actually stoned to death, on rumours of them being child lifters. Date 01.7.2018. Source: TV News. Similar cases reported across the country in Chennai, Bengal and Tripura where people have been attacked and killed on rumours of organ harvesting from kidnapped children. Such cases of mob attacks have been on the rise particularly after finding that the gau rakshaks who after attacking victims are left scot-free. 

4. In Mumbai, Italian banker raped in moving car. Date 01.7.2018.Source: TV News.

3. A woman thrashed, stripped and paraded naked in a Delhi locality on suspicion of eyeing the property of her landlady & having an affair with the landlady's son. The son's wife turned up with 4-5 women and did the gruesome deed. Date 30.6.2018.Source: National newspapers.

2.In Andhra seniors at a college raped a junior girl student over a year. Date 30.6.2018.Source: TV News.

1. The Mandsaur Rape Case where a 7 year old schoolgirl was thrashed, raped and killed by allowing her to bleed to death. Date 29.6.2018.Source: National newspapers & TV News.

                                                    ***************************

Vox Populi Issue 247

VOX POPULI                                              by                                        S Kamat                                                as                                       Aam Admi                   Issue: 247                        Date: 03.09.2018           Visit: skamat.blogspot.com or aamadmivoices.blogspot.com Contents:                 1. 'Raid-Raj' On Freedom Of Speech 2. Chronicling Emergency Like Actions In India Since 29 June 2018 3. Mud In The Face For Modi Over Failed Demonetisation Exercise

                                      'Raid-Raj' On Freedom Of Speech

  The arrest of the 5 activists with supposedly Maoist leanings along with 2 already in custody is a black mark on democracy in India. The coordinated arrests across India where these activists were located smacked of 'raid raj', this time not on tax defaulters but on those who consistently hold up their right to freedom of speech. As the Supreme Court rightly said while striking down the arrests and converting it to house arrest, dissent is an important part of democratic functioning. Otherwise democracy will grow in the manner that we have seen as in the way interpreted by those who govern us and in the absence of feedback and dissent will grow misshapen and may also get stunted in some areas in that process. It is clear from the information coming out that the Maharashtra police have acted in haste. Based on flimsy evidence they have arrested the activists and are now trying to defend their action desperately by exposing some of the evidence selectively to the public . For this they have already been pulled up by the Bombay High Court for holding a press conference when the matter was sub-judice. The unnecessary need to go public with information is clearly an attempt to justify their actions. However this attempt has boomeranged in their face since the evidence put out is amateurish and bizarre. In this day and age when the genre of spy stories and conspiracy theories are so popular the fact that intelligent and educated people will use terms like 'Rajiv Gandhi style of incident' in open letters and e-mails is in the realm of fiction. Even the assassins who killed Dabholkar and Gauri Lankesh used code words not only for the targets but also for the weapons that they were using and this information has been released by the police only. Thus the charge that the police is using planted or fabricated evidence against these activists seems likely to stick. There is no question that we need to go after those that tend to disrupt the tenor of our society but that should be done on both sides of the table, pro-government and anti-government, and even then on the basis of credible and irrefutable evidence. The present action against the 7 activists seems to be an over-reaction to the news that there is a plot to assassinate Narendra Modi. At his level these rumours should be a part of life since there will be many serious and non-serious elements thinking of such action. But it is up to the SPG to sift the wheat from the chaff and chase down the serious threats and the people behind it. In an election mode  that we are in for 2019 in the incident Modi will be open to the charge that he is trying to do this to get the sympathy of the voters since no one in their right minds would like him to be killed since he is the living embodiment of vanity and stupidity and is of more nuisance value alive than dead. Postscript: The fever about being killed has caught on with Shivraj Singh Chauhan, the MP CM claiming that there is a plot to kill him after his 'chariot' bus on campaign was pelted with stones. Nothing happened, no one was hurt and only a windowpane was broken. Now you will see one after another the BJP leaders, big and small will claim that there is someone out there plotting to kill them in a #meToo - Kill Scare campaign. 

               Chronicling Emergency Like Actions In India Since June 2018

Since 29.6.2018, I have been posting weekly on Facebook an update  of what I personally think are events that reflect the Emergency in this current government & in the BJP's actions as also on another head related to Law & Order inclusive of Crimes Against Women (this listing will follow in a subsequent issue of Vox Populi). I propose to continue this until the 2019 General Elections :

Emergency:
_____________

12. The arrest of the 5 activists last week is nothing short of a 'raid-raj' on freedom of speech in this country. The tendency to muzzle dissent was apparent from 2014 when secularism was mocked and intolerance promoted. Then it was the turn of students at JNU & Osmania University among other universities whose voices were proposed to be stifled with the intention of pursuing the intolerance agenda and looking to have the BJP youth wing to control the voices of these students through their unions. In the interim the raid-raj continued with the IT Dept. and the ED chasing down industrialists and businessmen. In India there is no person in business who can claim that he has nothing to hide. Thus the voice of the business community was clamped shut and there was nary a whimper from them on both Demonetisation and the GST launch, both of which were done shabbily. It then was the turn of the cow lynch brigades across India but mostly in BJP ruled States where indiscriminately and without verifying the antecedents people were killed, mostly Muslims and Dalits, for stealing, transporting and slaughtering of cattle. Some of these cases were avoidable since the victims were involved in their legitimate businesses. Now after a limited sojourn against journalists, it is the turn of activists to be branded as Maoists and victimised. Thus a state of 'terror' is being created to stop people from raising their voice and to generate a wave of opinion about the intentions of some people or groups of to de-stabilise the present government and to kill their leaders.  Is this not enough and more fertile grounds for the imposition of an Emergency? 

11. There is an issue of misinformation with the present BJP government which runs to epidemic proportions. But the more serious charge is that of suppressing information from the public which may be showing them in a bad light. This is tantamount to deliberate censorship which is against the fundamental right of freedom of speech. The example in this case was that recently some of the newspapers came up with the input that the decadal growth rates of the Indian economy during both the UPA-1 & UPA-2 governments were better than during the present BJP government. Within a couple of days of this news coming out it was seen that this information earlier available on the government website was quickly erased. A similar report was seen in the case of Jay Shah, Amit Shah's son, financial irregularities related to his business and property matters which was pulled out of the websites of the national media and a ban instituted on the matter by way of instructions to the media. 

10. An atmosphere of uncertainty and fear is again being created by the Kanwariyas violence first in Delhi and then Muzzafarpur where cars were vandalised and wrecked for just some contact with the pilgrims walking on the road. If you see the TV coverage of these two incidents, the driver in the Delhi case being a 25 year old woman and in the second instance not known, would be traumatised for life. The UP police have claimed that they are helpless to stop such incidents. The present government by their reluctance to take action is only encouraging more such incidents to take place since the perpetrators full well know that no punishment will follow for their actions. In the recent Alwar cow lynching case the accused have been seen making remarks openly on national TV that the government and police will support them to go scotfree. Ever since the BJP government came to power the same patterns have prevailed, first with the intolerance issue which had universities like JNU & Osmania in turmoil and then the cow lynching issue which has persisted with a footprint across the country for the last 2 years or more and now the Kanwariyas violence. This was what happened the last time that Emergency was seen in this country which is happening again with fear and uncertainty prevailing among the citizens as a lead up to another Emergency.

9. There have been a couple of situations relating to the construction of our highways around the country which smack of high-handed behaviour by both the State as well as Central governments. The incidents cited here relating to the above are also against the principle of federalism enshrined in our Constitution. It is reported that in the construction of another expressway between Salem and Chennai in Tamil Nadu, the police are using strong arm tactics to enforce the decision to acquire fertile agricultural lands from the farmers. Those unwilling to hand over their land are finding the police barging into their homes and forcibly evicting them. It is being said that such action is being done at the behest of the Centre by the present AIDMK State government which is now at the mercy of the BJP-led NDA government at the Centre for its survival. In another incident in adjoining Kerala the bypass for a highway near Kannur is being politicised in the face of farmers unwilling to part with their fertile land again and activist protests. The Centre had called for a meeting to resolve the matter by calling the pro and anti elements related to the project along with the Central Minister from Kerala but without the representatives or ministers of the incumbent CPM led government in Kerala. Ignoring the State government for an important project deliberately smacks of unilateralism and goes against the spirit of federalism. 

8. Bank deposits limited liability bill proposed to be moved limiting the payout to Rs. 1 Lakh irrespective of the size of the deposits with the bank in the event of it going bankrupt. In the context of all PSB's reeling under the NPA scams there is every chance of every PS Bank going bankrupt. Hence seems to be a deliberate attempt to shortchange depositor and hijack his money by the government. This is a personal worst case scenario prediction. With an Emergency likely to be imposed upon what the 2019 election results will show in the event of a hung result, the PSB's and some of the major private Banks like ICICI will put up their 'true' balance sheets showing the NPA's in their proper accounting method, as a consequence of which most Banks will go belly-up and into liquidation. It is then that the citizens Bank Deposits will be appropriated and you will end up getting a maximum of Rs. 1 Lakh irrespective on whether you are holding sizeable higher deposits with the bank. 

7. Government moving amendment to RTI Act to make it more difficult for citizens to get information from government. Introduced in July 2018 Monsoon session of Parliament but deferred upon objections from Opposition. 

6. An actor, Siddhartha Narayan of Rang De Basanti fame, was trolled by the rightist trolling mafia for tweeting against the Alwar cow lynching case of Rakbar Khan. Shows intolerance to personal beliefs and their projection on public platforms. Date: 25.7.2018. Source: National newspapers.

5. A Dalit man, Lovely Kumar was thrashed by a group of upper caste Jats in Quila Parikshatgarh town of Meerut Dist. U.P. And the act was filmed and posted on social media to instill fear in other Dalits. The man was forced to abuse himself, his community and Babasaheb Ambedkar by the assailants. Shows intolerance to lower class communities and not allowing them to go about their normal lives. Date: 25.7.2018. Source: National newspapers.

4. Swami Agnivesh attacked, again by Bharatiya Yuva Janata Morcha (BYJM) goons while he was going about his normal activities in Jharkhand. This is an infringement on fundamental rights to pursue his beliefs and on freedom of speech. Date: 18.7.2018. Source: National newspapers & TV News.Z

3. Shashi Tharoor, MP for Thiruvananthapuram, office in the Kerala capital was vandalised by youths suspected  to belong to the Bharatiya Yuva Janata Morcha (BYJM), for his comments about the BJP leading India into a Hindu Pakistan if they happen to win the 2019 general elections. Issue relates to an attempt to suppress freedom of speech.  Tharoor may have been a bit out of line when he made that comment since we are not very comfortable with Pakistan analogies but there are other civilised forums for redressal rather than resorting to violence and intimidation. Date: 17.7.2018.Source: National newspapers.

2. For the PM's rally in Jaipur on 7.7.2018 security was not allowing anything with the colour black not even clothes or dresses into the venue for fear of spontaneous protests while the rally was in progress. Date 8.7.2018.Source: National newsspapers.

1.  Uttarakhand CM ordering the arrest of an elderly woman schoolteacher who had come to his Janata Darbar requesting for a transfer. Her offence - she argued with the CM. The police later released the schoolteacher on a personal bail bond. Related information, the CM's wife remains in the same school though she was promoted and transferred in 2008, 10 years ago. Date 29.6.2018.Source: TV News.

                Mud In The Face For Modi Over Failed Demonetisation Exercise 

The cat is finally out of the bag! The RBI has come out after two long years that 99.3% of the demonetised Rs. 500 & Rs. 1000 notes have come back. The counting process because of many variables may have some errors but taking the figures of RBI as the truth the government in terms of its stated objective to unearth and appropriate black money through the demonetisation exercise failed to even recover the cost of printing the new currency notes which was in excess of Rs. 10,000 crores. But even then some of the limited minds within the BJP are patting themselves on the back saying that the 0.7% of the demonetised notes which did not come back and which comprises about Rs. 10,300 crores is the black money that they have unearthed! They little realise that this amount is a drop in the bucket in the ocean of black money which runs into lakhs of crores and was reported once as equal to our GDP. With almost all the demonetised notes having come back, this puts Narendra Modi in a piquant position since from his promise of transferring Rs. 15 Lakhs to each citizen's account just after taking office in   2014 upon waging war on black money, he is left in an embarrassing position with no black money from abroad having come back and neither has he been able to unearth any of the black money within the country. The Rs. 10,300 crores as above will not even be enough to transfer Rs. 100 to every citizen. This once again shows that the present BJP government is full of bluff and bluster, tall in promises particularly during election campaigns but having to eat crow when almost every initiative of theirs having fallen by the wayside because of bad implementation and the inability to think through a process.  The fact that the demonetisation exercise failed requires that accountability for this should be established and even if Narendra Modi does not resign taking moral responsibility, Adhia should be summarily dismissed from service and Das' retirement benefits be immediately suspended for causing death and untold misery to Indian citizens during the putting through of this exercise. The fact that only Rs. 10,300 crores remained unaccounted shows again how nimble footed the black money holders are, keeping one step ahead always of the government's interception measures and its enforcement authorities. Postscript: Lately Arun Jaitley, our esteemed Finance Minister has said that the demonetisation exercise did at the least expand the tax base for income tax payers. That was not one of the objectives listed for demonetisation in 2016 when it was put through. These are all afterthoughts now to justify the exercise in the manner of a drowning man clutching at straws or using a sledgehammer to kill an ant. The primary objective of recovering black money by way of demonetisation has failed miserably. The tunes about the objectives for demonetisation are constantly changing from the originally stated in the format of a Remix Music Video and joining the chorus is Rajeev Kumar, Vice Chairman, Niti Aayog, who put the blame for the economic slump post-2016 squarely on the ex-Governor of the RBI, Raghuram Rajan and that too for pursuing the re-classification of NPA's. Rajeev Kumar was singing a different tune just 6 months before being appointed as Vice Chairman, Niti Aayog, about the needlessness of the demonetisation exercise and its implantation lacunae. But now ensconced in the official chair he is standing up on his hind feet and pleasing his masters. The government, Arun Jaitley and Rajeev Kumar may like to explain why from 2014 the NPA's have climbed from Rs. 1 Lakh Crores to an estimated Rs. 12 Lakh Crores now with our banking system. Why were the availers of loans conscious of paying up against the loans to avoid them becoming NPA's prior to 2014 and after that they suddenly stopped? Was it because of the lax approach of the new BJP government in not pursuing these people? Surely this needs to be examined. Narendra Modi has not learnt his lesson yet from his promise of bringing back a Black Money and Demonetisation, which both failed miserably and was just last week continuing to claim that every single Rupee of the NPA's he would recover! This is sheer stupidity but good entertainment. That's what Narendra Modi is all about. 

                                                 ******************************